Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas

Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas

Spatial analysis of resilience of rural settlements against earthquake risk (case study: Nair County)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD student, Department of Geography and Rural Planning, Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Geography and Rural Planning, Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran
3 Associate Professor, Department of Geography and Rural Planning, Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran
4 Professor, Department of Geomorphology, Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran
Abstract
Introduction

Today, the perspectives and theories of disaster management and sustainable development seek to create resilient communities against natural hazards, which are considered inevitable phenomena that always pose a serious threat to development, especially in rural areas. Natural hazards, with their various types and extensive reach, have always existed throughout the life of the Earth as recurring and destructive phenomena, and they continue to represent a serious danger to humanity after the emergence of humans (Portaheri et al, 2010: 32). Environmental hazards are occurring not only in increasing numbers but also with greater diversity and levels of damage, particularly in rural areas. Nevertheless, they are unavoidable phenomena, and the only way to cope with them is through their management (Villagra, 2017: 662).
Given the environmental conditions and geographical location of Iran, it is evident that the country is exposed to various hazards, with approximately 31 types of hazards occurring in Iran out of the 40 identified globally (Azadeh et al. 2017: 74). Consequently, Iran is among the countries with a very high vulnerability to disasters and natural hazards, ranking among the top ten disaster-prone countries in the world (Behtash et al. 2013: 10). The villages in the Niyr district, like other villages in the country, grapple with natural disasters, and to date, the rural housing in this area has not followed a specific structure or form and has not been built according to technical standards. In this context, the occurrence of natural disasters has consistently had detrimental effects on rural settlements.
In this regard, the concept of resilience in rural areas is raised. Considering that the rural areas of Nir County are constantly at risk of earthquakes and are among the most affected by this hazard, the present study aims to analyze the spatial status of resilience in the rural settlements of Nir County against earthquakes

Methodology

The present research is of the "applied" type and, in terms of nature and method, it is of the "descriptive-analytical" type. In order to collect data and information, two methods were used: 1) library-documentary methods and 2) field-survey methods. The spatial scope of the research includes the villages of Nir County, located in Ardabil Province. To select sample households within the villages of Nir County in Ardabil Province, due to the large number of villages in this county, sampling was conducted from all villages. With the input of university professors, advisors, and researchers in the field of rural studies and environmental hazards, 30% of the villages were selected as sample villages.

Results

The descriptive findings of the research indicate that out of 368 respondents, 59.5% were male and 40.5% were female. Among them, 87.8% were married, with the highest number of respondents falling in the age group of 31 to 40 years at 25%, followed by the 41 to 50 years’ age group at 21.7%. In terms of education level, the largest number of respondents had a high school diploma at 25.5%, while 15.5% had completed elementary and middle school education. Regarding employment, it can be stated that the majority of respondents were engaged in livestock farming, agriculture, and gardening, with 18.2% and 16.8% respectively. In terms of monthly income, the results showed that the largest number of respondents (29.6%) earned between 6 to 8 million tomans per month, while 21.2% earned between 8 to 10 million tomans per month. The smallest percentage, at 15.8%, earned less than 4 million tomans per month. Additionally, regarding residential housing, 20.1% of the rural homes studied were newly built, 24.7% were renovated, 26.1% were dilapidated, and 29.1% were other types of construction. Therefore, it must be stated that the housing conditions of the rural residents in the studied area are not at a standard level and require special attention from responsible organizations and the community.
 
4.Discussion and Conclusion
The aim of this research is to analyze the spatial status of resilience in rural settlements against the earthquake hazard in the Nir County of Ardabil Province. The results indicate that the housing conditions of rural residents in the studied area do not meet standard levels, and in the event of an earthquake, it could lead to significant human and financial losses for the villagers. It is essential for the relevant authorities, especially the Housing Foundation of the Islamic Revolution in Nir County and the crisis management of this county and Ardabil Province, to pay special attention to this issue.
Furthermore, the ranking of sample villages in terms of rural resilience against the earthquake hazard using the Copras multi-criteria decision-making technique revealed that the villages of Virsagh (Qi=1), Dushanlu (Qi=0.99), Inalu (Qi=0.94), and Takbalagh (Qi=0.93) rank first to fourth in terms of resilience (rural resilience) against the natural hazard of earthquakes and have a favorable status compared to other sample villages. In contrast, the villages of Barjalu (Qi=0.345), Qurtolmosh (Qi=0.356), Khanem Balakandi (Qi=0.368), and Saqzchi (Qi=0.392) exhibit significantly lower resilience against the natural disaster of earthquakes based on twelve research indicators.
Thus, it can be stated that 39.9% of the villages in this county do not have a favorable status in terms of resilience against earthquakes, particularly concerning indicators such as supportive policies, recovery to suitable conditions, income and employment, participation, awareness and knowledge, networks, norms, institutional framework, institutional relations, institutional performance, vital arteries, and critical infrastructure. In the event of such a crisis, these villages will face numerous challenges.
Regarding spatial distribution, the pattern of spatial distribution of rural resilience in Nir County against earthquake hazards is random and arbitrary. Some sample villages that are close to the main fault or even at a considerable distance from it have inadequate resilience. Geographically, villages located in the southern, southwestern, and northeastern parts of Nir County are in a poor state of resilience, while those situated in the northern part of this county exhibit higher levels of resilience.
Keywords

Anabestani, A. Javanshiri, M. Mahmoodi, H. Darban Astaneh, M. 2018. Spatial analysis of resilience level of rural settlements against environmental hazards (case study: central part of Faruj city). Journal of Spatial Analysis of Environmental Hazards. 5 (5), 17-38.
Azadeh, S R. Taghavi, M. 2017. Spatial analysis of the vulnerability of urban and rural settlements to earthquake risk (case study: Gilan province), Journal of Spatial Analysis of Environmental Hazards, No. 4(3), pp. 71-84.
Badri, S A. Ramazanzadeh, M. Ghadiri Masoom, M. 2014. The role of local management in promoting local resilience against natural disasters with an emphasis on floods, a case study: two basins of Cheshme Kila, Tankabon and Sardabroud, Kalardasht, Crisis Management Journal, No. 1(2): pp. 37-48.
Bazrafshan, J. Tulabinjad, M. Tulabinjad, M. 2018. Spatial analysis of resilience differences in urban and rural areas against natural hazards (case study: Pol Dokhtar city), Rural Research, 9(1), pp. 116-135.
Behtash, F. Kinjad, M. Pirbabaie, M A. Asghari, A. 2013. Evaluation and analysis of dimensions and components of the resilience of Tabriz metropolis, Journal of Fine Arts - Architecture and Urbanism, 18(3), pp. 33-42.
Fakhr Qazi, Mona. Poor Ramazan, I, Moulai Hashjin, N A. Economic resilience of rural settlements in Auj city against environmental hazards with an emphasis on earthquakes, Volume 11, Number 43. 57-76.
Farahani, H. Abbasi, F. 2021. Analysis of resilience components of rural settlements against earthquake risk (Case study: Ijroud city, Zanjan province), Journal of Studies of Human Settlements Planning, Published online on January 20, 2021.
Faraji Sabokbar, H. Tahmasbi, B. Ghorbani, M. Sarmadi, A A. Soltani, N A. 2020. Assessing the vulnerability of rural settlements in Iran against earthquake risk. Number 174. 103-118.
Folke, C. Carpenter, S. R. Walker, B. Scheffer, M. Chapin, T. Rockström, J (2010) Resilience Thinking: Integrating Resilience, Adaptability and Transformability, Ecology and Society 15(4), 1-9.
Hassanvand, A. Hajinejad, A. Ysouri, M. 2019. The Factors Affecting Economic Resilience of Rural Settlements after the Earthquake (Case Study: Silahkhor Rural District, Dorood). Scientific Journal of Geography and Environmental Hazards, Volume 8, Issue 4 - Serial Number 32, Pages 51-66.
Kapucu, Naim, V. Hawkins, Christopher, I. Rivera, Fernando (2013). Disaster Preparedness and Resilience for Rural Communities, Risk, Hazards & Crisis in Public Policy, Vol. 4, No. 4, 2013.
Nori, H. Sepahvand, F. 2016. Resilience analysis of rural settlements against natural hazards with an emphasis on earthquakes (case study: Shirvan village, Borujerd city), Rural Research Journal, No. 7 (2), pp. 272-285.
Norozi, A. 2017. Basics of Crisis Management in Rural Areas, Jihad University Press, Isfahan.
Norozi, A. 2019. Measuring the resilience of rural settlements against environmental hazards (case study: Beldaji district), Physical Development Planning Journal, year 4, number 3 (15 series), 73-88.
Petak, W. (2002). Earthquake resilience through mitigation: a system approach. Paper presented at the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, 12 Sep 2002, Laxenburg, Austria.
Portaheri, M, Hajinjad, A. Fatahi, A. Nemati, R. 2014. Assessing the physical vulnerability of rural settlements against natural hazards (earthquakes) using a decision-making model.
Portaheri, M, Sejasi, H, Sadeghlou, T. 2010. Comparative evaluation of natural hazard rating methods in rural areas (case study: Zanjan province), Journal of rural researches, No 7, 31-54.
Rafieian, M., Rezaei, M. R., Askari, A., Parhizkar A., & Shayan, S. (2011). [Explaining the concept of resilience index of communitybased disaster management (CBDM) (Persian)]. Journal of Spatial Planning, 15(4), 19-41.
Rajabi, M, Hejazi, A, Rustaie, Sh. Ali, N. 2018. Vulnerability zoning of natural and geomorphological hazards in rural settlements of Saqez city (flood and earthquake case study), Year 7, Number 2, 183-195.
Rose, A. (2007). Economic resilience to natural and man-made disasters: Multidisciplinary origins and contextual dimensions. Environmental Hazards, 7(4), 38-98.
Sadeghlou, T. Sejasi GHedari, H. 2014. Prioritization of effective factors on increasing the resilience of farmers against natural hazards with an emphasis on drought (study area: farmers in the villages of Ijroud), Journal of Geography and Environmental Hazards. No. 3 (2), pp. 129-154.
Schouten, M, Vanderheide, M. Heijman (2009) resilience of social-ecological systems in European rural areas: theory and prospects, 113th EAAE seminar “the role of knowledge, innovation and human capital in multifunctional agriculture and territorial rural development”, Belgrade, Republic of Serbia, 1-11.
Valaei, M. Abdullahi, A. Eskanderzadeh, I. Hosseinzade, A. Zarbi, H. 2020. Analysis of the role of rural management in increasing the resilience of villagers against drought (case study: Miandoab city). Scientific Quarterly Journal of Human Settlements Planning Studies, Volume 15, Number 3 (52 consecutive).
Villagra, P.; Quintana, C. Disaster Governance for Community Resilience in Coastal Towns: Chilean Case Studies. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2017, 14, 1063.
Yeganeh, A, Shafiee, A; Bokaeii, A. 2022. Analysis of economic and social resilience of gardeners against drought and its effective factors (Case study: Central part of Malekan county). Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas, 3(1), 161-180.
Zhao, Liang, He, Fanneng (2020), A Framework of Resilience Development for Poor Villages after the Wenchuan Earthquake Based on the Principle of “Build Back Better, Sustainability 2020, 12, 4979; doi:10.3390/su12124979.