Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas

Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas

Factors Influencing the Reduction of Physical Vulnerability of Urban Fabrics in Talesh Against Earthquakes, Emphasizing the Reconstruction and Renovation Approach

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Ph.D. student, Geography and Urban Planning, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ardabil, Iran.
2 Associate Professor Department of Geography, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ardabil, Iran
3 Assistant Professor of Geography and Urban Planning, Ardabil Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ardabil, Iran.
Abstract
Introduction

Natural hazards are natural processes or phenomena that constitute a threat to human life, property, livelihoods, and services, which might trigger a disaster (Kavoosi & et al., 2018). Among these threats that are most hazardous, most damaging, and, when occurring at great scales, least forgiving in terms of resulting in human casualties and financial losses are earthquakes. Earthquakes that strike urban areas bring devastation to a nation's urban development efforts and pose widespread damages across various levels. Thus, reconstruction and rehabilitation stand out as very important methods in mitigating urban earthquake vulnerability.
Studies show that cities in the Gilan Province harbor the highest levels of human resources, investments, economies, and infrastructures. However, excessive centralization; unprincipled placement of risky land uses, such as fossil fuel stations, airports et cetera; collapse of access standards (suitability of structures and pathways); prevalence of quite a number of bridges (underpasses, river-crossing bridges); neglect of river boundaries and climatic elements (prevailing winds, precipitation in construction); and the lack of balanced and standardized access distances regarding the distribution of emergency and rescue centers such as hospitals, fire stations, etc., impose major security threats and vulnerabilities on its cities.
city of Talesh is no exception to these problems. Located in the western region of Gilan, Talesh occupies 25% of the Gilan area, being surrounded on three sides by the Talesh Mountains (which form part of the Alborz range) and on another side by the Caspian Sea. Traditionally, since its inception, this city has suffered from natural disasters, floods and earthquakes chiefly among them. Lying next to a fault line, the city is susceptible to earthquakes. Hence, the researcher will address the various factors that affect the urban fabric's vulnerability reduction to earthquakes in the case of Talesh while focusing on reconstruction and renovation strategies. The above provides an insight into the central question the authors want to address:
What is the causal, contextual, and intervening factors influencing the reduction of urban fabric vulnerability in Talesh to earthquakes with an emphasis on reconstruction and renovation? And which hold the greatest significance?
 

Methodology

This study is applied in nature, with an interpretive and analytical essence. It combines qualitative and quantitative approaches. Information analysis is performed using the grounded theory method and the FARAS model. The statistical population includes experts and specialists in the study field. The sample community was collected through purposive sampling, resulting in 30 participants.
 

Results

Based on the findings, the causal factors for a decrease in physical vulnerability in the city of Talesh against earthquakes are decentralized urban development planning, increased institutional and physical resilience, and integrated management across different organizations. Contextual factors include building a database for Talesh, increasing awareness toward earthquake vulnerability in the physical environment, technical facilities, promoting dialogue and knowledge sharing for vulnerability reduction, and taking reconstruction and refurbishment into account for urban fabric security against earthquakes. Intervention factors identified included documentation and performance evaluation of organizations for physical vulnerability reduction, drafting regulations and overall strategies among relevant organizations, and forming specialized committees. The FARAS fuzzy model results indicate that integrated organizational management (weight: 0.420), dialogue and knowledge exchange (weight: 0.430), and drafting unified regulations (weight: 0.426) are given the highest importance for decreasing Talesh vulnerability to earthquakes.

Discussion

Integrated management across organizations emerged as the key causes for reduction of earthquake vulnerability for Talesh. There are numerous decision-making centers that create strong obstacles on the path of earthquake vulnerability reduction in Talesh which further emphasizes the necessity of decreasing the number of these centers. In context, effective factors are exchange and ideas, whereas specialists mention benefits in the shared knowledge of executive managers between organizations like the governor's office and municipalities. This collaboration could become a major strength in reducing physical vulnerability. Finally, it's more important than any other impact factor to formulate general legislation on renovation and reconstruction of urban fabrics.
 

Conclusion

Identifying causal, contextual, and intervening factors enables recognition of Talesh city's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats concerning earthquake risks. Implementing the necessary strategies can minimize financial and physical damages to the city.
 
Acknowledgments
This article is derived from the doctoral dissertation of Mr. Dariush Mohammadi-Outari, which was defended at the Ardabil Branch of the Islamic Azad University.
Keywords

Abdullahi, M. 2013. Crisis management in urban areas. Publications of the Organization of Municipalities and Villages of the country, Ministry of Interior.
Ahadnejad Raveshti, M., Teymouri, A., Tahmasebi Moghaddam, H., & Vaezlivari, M. (2020). Spatial analysis of road network vulnerability against earthquake with Approach Crisis Management (The Case of Zanjan Downtown). Journal of Natural Environmental Hazards, 9(26), 77-90. doi: 10.22111/jneh.2020.32365.1583
Amjad, M., & Soltani, I. (2020). Strategic Planning to Reduce the Vulnerability of Historical Textures Case study: Historical Texture of Yazd City. Emergency Management, 8(2), 17-32.
Bahraini, H., Izadi, M., & Mofidi, M. (2014). The Approaches and Policies of Urban Renewal from" Urban Reconstruction" to "Sustainable Urban Regeneration". Motaleate Shahri, 3(9), 17-30.
Feshharaki, Seyedjavad and Mahmoodzadeh, Amir. 2013. Descriptive culture of passive defense, Alm Afarin Publishing House, Isfahan.
Hajipour, Khalil. 2016. An introduction to the evolution and development of urban restoration approaches (time period after the First World War to the beginning of the third millennium). Andisheh Iranshahr, a quarterly magazine in the field of urbanism. second year Number nine and ten.
Hamidi, M. 1995. Evaluation of land segmentation and urban context in the vulnerability of housing from natural disasters. Proceedings of the Seminar on Housing Development Policies of Iran.
Hataminejad, Hossein, Fathi, Seyedhamid and Eshgabadi, Farshid. 2018. Assessing the level of seismic vulnerability in the city: the case study of District 10 of Tehran Municipality. Researches of human geography. Number 68.
Heikkala, S. G. (1982). Urban Scale Vulnerability. Proceedings of the U.S-Italy Colloquium on urban design and earthquake hazard mitigation. University of Washington and university of Rome
Jones, B, G. (1982). Planning for the reconstruction of earthquake stricken communities. Proceedings of the P.R.C of
Karimi Baseri, S., & shahabzadeh, M. (2023). Identifying the drivers of crisis management in the central context of Shiraz with a passive defense approach. Emergency Management, 11, 127-148.
Kavoosi, F., Saberi, A., Rangzan, K., & hosein zadeh, M. (2018). Analyzing the Level of Risk in Urban Areas for Crisis Management After Earthquake Using FAHP method in GIS (Case study: 1th district of Ahvaz). Geography and Development, 16(50), 161-180. doi: 10.22111/gdij.2018.3571
Kermanshah, A., Derrible, S., 2016. A geographical and multi-criteria vulnerability assessment of transportation networks against extreme earthquakes. Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf. 153, 39–49.
Kitchin, R. Dodge, M. 2020. The (In) Security of Smart Cities: Vulnerabilities, Risks, Mitigation, and Prevention. Smart Cities and Innovative Urban Technologies. EBook ISBN9781003132851.
Kreimer, Arnold, and Carlin (2003). “Building Safer Cities; the Future of Disaster Risk “
Maleki K, Taleshi M, Heidari Far M R. (2023), Analyzing of Threat network and hazard ring in earthquake risk with passive defense approach (Case study: Kermanshah metropolis). Journal of Spatial Analysis Environmental Hazards; 9 (4) :57-80 Management, Vol 15, No.3, Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
More, Tun Lin and pathranakul, P. (2006). An Integrated Approach to NaturalDisaster Prevention and
Mortezazadeh A. (2024). Investigating the effect of developing knowledge and technology to reduce earthquake risk on crisis management. JHRE. 43(185), 123-132.doi: https://doi.org/10.22034/43.185.123
Paton, Douglas and Fohnston, David (2001). Disasterand Communities: Vulnerability Resilience and Preparedness, Disaster prevention and management, MCB University, Vol, No 4, ISSN 0965- 3562
Poyan, H., sanayei, A., & ansari, A. (2020). Urban Tissue Urban Modeling under Different Scenarios for Managing Crisis Against Earthquakes: Case Study of Tehran Municipality Area. Human Geography Research, 52(4), 1275-1293. doi: 10.22059/jhgr.2019.285435.1007977
Rahnamayi, Mohammad Taghi. Salah Kar, Sabra. Hosseini Amini, Hassan. 2013. An analysis of the urban system of Rasht from the point of view of passive defense. The 6th Congress of Iran's Geopolitical Association of Passive Defense
Roberts Marion. 2013. Urban design and urban revitalization. Translator: Maalemi, Bahram. Haft Shahr Quarterly
Shokohi, Mohammad Anzaz. Minaei, Masoud. Moniri Moghadam, Azadeh. (2021). Analysis of influential indicators in crisis management (case study: District 11 of Mashhad Municipality). Zagros Landscape Geography and Urban Planning Quarterly. 13 (48). 67-89
Shova, Thomas (1996), the origins of the urban crisis, Princetion, University Press, Princetio
Soleymani, M, Aminzade, B, Huq, S.A. 2021. Evaluation of Physical Urban Management Strategies in Major Crisis Management Policies: A Case Study on Earthquake Crisis in Tehran Zone One, Journal of Transport & Health, Volume 22, 101200.the proceeding of the of the eighth of the eighth world conference on earthouake engineering, San Francisco, California U.S.A. Joint workshop architecture, urban planning and engineers.
UNDP (2004). Reducing Disaster Risk, A challenge for Developmen
Xu, J, Lu, Y. 2018. Towards an earthquake-resilient world: from post disaster reconstruction to pre-disaster prevention. Environmental Hazards. 17(4). PP 269-275.
Ye. Y. (1984). Urban earthquake disaster mitigation through architectural design and urban planning. Proceedings of