Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas

Journal of Geographical Studies of Mountainous Areas

Investigating conflict management in urban land use realization(Case of study: Saman region of Mashhad)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Master of Urban Planning, Urban Engineering Department, Faculty of Arts, University of Bojnord, Bojnord, Iran
2 Associate Prof. Department of Urban Engineering, Faculty of Arts, Bojnord University, Bojnord, Iran
Abstract
Introduction

Conflict is one of the most important and prominent aspects of social life. Conflict at different levels and degrees has brought beneficial or destructive effects. Attention to negative effects has led experts to adopt a negative attitude towards conflict, and in contrast, experts who consider effects such as growth, progress, creativity and effectiveness as the results of conflict emphasize the functional and positive aspects of conflict.
 

Methodology

The present study is applied in terms of purpose and descriptive-analytical in terms of method. It was conducted in the form of a field and survey based on the Thomas Kilman model and Afzal Rahim's standard questionnaire (1983). The questionnaire was designed based on a five-option Likert scale (very high, high, medium, low, very low) for the extent of use of conflict management techniques in the feasibility of land use in the Samen region and includes three sections: general information of the respondent, questionnaire guide (definitions of conflict management techniques and introduction of the target group), and questions related to the five conflict management techniques. In addition to providing descriptive statistics of the data, data analysis was carried out through inferential statistics and statistical tests, including: Pearson's correlation coefficient and eta correlation coefficient, using Spss26 software.

Results

The results indicate that the use of conflict management techniques is in line with top-down planning and there is no executive mechanism for effective conflict management in line with the interests of all actors, and conflicts are managed in line with the interests of those in power through dominance or avoidance.
Also, According to the results of the eta correlation coefficient test in Figure (5), it was found that the level of use of conflict management techniques by the agents and executive managers in the process of land use realization in the Samen region of Mashhad was different for four groups: urban managers, people, developers (investors and contractors), and specialists (consulting engineers of the detailed plan), and there are significant relationships between conflict management styles and the type of audience. Thus, the cooperation technique with 0.96, compromise with 0.95, and reconciliation with 0.91 had the highest correlation coefficient and the highest level of significance with the type of audience, and the avoidance technique with a correlation coefficient of 0.48 and the dominance technique with 0.32 had the lowest correlation with the type of audience. 
 

Discussion

Comparing the results of the present study with other studies, it can be said that the results of Demchuk et al.'s (2022) study also showed that the way conflicts are managed in urban communities and against different groups varies regionally and locally, and can be in the form of cooperation and mobilization, avoidance, or authoritarianism.The research of Ebrahimzadeh et al. (2023) also showed that the conflict management variable has a complete mediating role in the relationship between social capital and institutional effectiveness. In this regard, the results of the present study also showed that conflict management styles and how they are used can be effective in the feasibility of urban land use. The results of the study of Goodarzi (2018) also showed that the use of conflict management techniques against the employer, contractor, and consultant is different, and the use of reconciliation and cooperation techniques reduces the level of conflicts and improves the quality of relationships. The results of the present study also showed that the way in which conflict is managed by the agents and executive managers in the process of land use realization in the Samen region is different from that of urban managers, developers, people, and experts, and conflict management styles can be effective in improving the state of urban land use realization. It seems that what is important in research in the field of conflict management and can be part of future research is how and how to implement conflict management techniques between interested and influential actors. In fact, the implementation and effectiveness of conflict management is possible in line with combined top-down and bottom-up programs.
 

Conclusion

As shown in Figure (7), there is a direct and significant relationship between cooperation and compromise. This means that managers and executive agents have compromised more with their audience to increase cooperation in solving problems that have arisen in the process of realizing urban land use in the Samen region. There is also a direct and significant relationship between the level of dominance and compromise. This means that managers and executive agents have increased the level of compromise to resolve disputes in the process of realizing land use in the Samen region by using dominance over their audience. In addition, there is a significant and direct relationship between the level of compromise and avoidance.
In this study, it was found that there are significant relationships between the cooperation and compromise techniques with a correlation coefficient of 0.47, between the domination and compromise techniques with a correlation coefficient of 0.6, and between the compromise and avoidance techniques with a correlation coefficient of 0.57. This means that when the agents and executives have shown a tendency to cooperate, they have shown more compromise and have given up some of their demands in response to the needs of the other party. When they have tried to compromise and provide a middle ground between the needs of the parties but have not achieved the desired result, they have tried to exert influence and dominate the other party. In situations where even compromise has not yielded the desired result in resolving disputes, the agents and executives have tried to withdraw and avoid conflicts.
Keywords

Ahani, S., & Dadashpoor, H. (2021). Land conflict management measures in peri-urban areas: a meta-synthesis review. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 64(11),1909-1939. https://doi.org/10.1080/09640568.2020.1852916
Asgharpour Masouleh, A. (2013). Trust & cooperation in urban renewal. Tehran: Tisa Publications. (In Persian)
Asgharpour Masouleh, A., Behravan, H., Noghani, M., Yousefi, A. (2010). Analysis of collective actions and its application to the case of the dilapidated fabric of the Samen area in Mashhad. Journal of Social Sciences of Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. 6(2), 151-180. https://doi.org/10.22067/jss.v0i0.8773. (In Persian)
Babaeian Jelodar, M., & Wing Yiu, T. (2012). Systematic framework of conflict, dispute and relationship quality in construction projects. Sustainable Procurement (The University of New South Wales, Australia), 276-285. 10.5130/ajceb. v15i1.4281.
Babaeian Jelodar, M., Yiu, T., & Wilkinson, S. (2015). Systematic Representation of Relationship Quality in Conflict and Dispute: for Construction Projects. Construction Economics and Building, 15 (1), 89-103.http://dx.doi.org/10.5130/ajceb.v15i1.4281.
Bahrabadi, A., Babakhani, Malihe. (2001). Land use planning with the aim of optimizing energy consumption in line with sustainable urban development (case study: District 2, Zone 8 of Tehran), Journal of Economics and Urban Planning, 3(2), 6-20. 10.22034/UEP.2022.316731.1140(In Persian)
Barani, M., Abdullahzadeh Taraf, A., & Faramarzi Asl, M. (2023). Recreating the historical and cultural texture of Urmia city to achieve sustainable development, Journal of Economics and Urban Planning, 4(2), 96-112. 10.22034/UEP.2023.393647.1353 .(In Persian)
Behrouzi, M., Majidi, H., and Saeideh Zarabadi, Z. (2012). Explaining the criteria for promoting a sense of attachment to place with a design-oriented planning approach (Parand City), Journal of Economics and Urban Planning, 4(3), 52-63. 10.22034/UEP.2022.365320.1287
Chapin, Stuart, Kaiser, Edward and Gadzchak, David. (2014). Urban Land Use Planning. Translated by Manouchehr Tabibiyan. Tehran: Tehran University Press. (In Persian)
Charles, I., & Chukwunonye Abovu, A. (2023). Conflict Management Strategy and Insecurity in Kaduna State, 2010-2021. International Journal of Research Publication and Reviews, Vol 4, no 1, pp 1380-1396.
Christie, D. J., Wagner, R. V., & Nann Winter, D. D. (2001). PEACE, CONFLICT, AND VIOLENCE (Peace Psychology for the 21 st Century). United States of America: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Demchuk, A., Mišić, M., Obydenkova, A., & Tosun, J. (2022). Environmental conflict management: a comparative cross-cultural perspective of China and Russia. Post-Communist Economies, 34(7):871-893. https://doi.org/10.1080/14631377.2021.1943915.
Diab, A., Pabbajah, M., Widyanti, R., Muthalib, L., & Widyatmoko, W. (2022). Accommodation of local wisdom in conflict resolution of Indonesia’s urban society. Cogent Social Sciences, 1(8):2153413. https://doi.org/10.1080/23311886.2022.2153413.
Ebrahim Zadeh, N., Sharif Zadeh, M., Abdullah Zadeh, Gh., and Rezaei, R. (2013). The relationship between social capital and conflict management and its impact on institutional effectiveness in rural cooperatives in Gorgan city. Quarterly Journal of Cooperatives and Agriculture. 12(45), 86-104. 10.22034/AJCOOP.2023.362562.1802. (In Persian)
Ebrahimi Bozani, M., Zamani Joharestani, A. (2013). An analysis of the feasibility of land use planning for the comprehensive plan of Malayer city. Quarterly Journal of Urban Ecology Research. 12(2), 119-137. 10.30473/GRUP.2021.8659.(In Persian)
Goodarzi, M. (2018). Studying the effect of conflict management styles on the quality of relations between the pillars of three-factor construction projects in Iran. Master's thesis in anthropology, Urban Planning Department, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, University of Arts. (In Persian)
Ghaedrahmati, S., Rezaali, M., Hashemi Zehi, S. and Javan, F. (2017). Components influencing promotion of social interactions in urban parks (Case Study: Zabol City). Human Geography Research, 49(4), 901-915. doi: 10.22059/jhgr.2017.61741(In Persian)
Goodarzi, S. (2009). Application of Statistics in Social Sciences. Tuyserkan: Tuyserkan Azad University in Cooperation with Sociologists Publications. (In Persian)
Habibpour Getabi, K., Safari Shomali, R. (2009). Comprehensive Guide to Using SPSS in Survey Research. Tehran: Loya Publications. (In Persian)
Islam, N., & Rimi, N. (2017). Conflict Management Technique in Private Commercial Banks of Bangladesh: An Application of Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Handling Model. European Journal of Business and Management, Vol.9, No.29,p:91-99.
Kafashi, M. (2012). Application of Descriptive Statistics in Social Research. Tehran: Sociologists Publications. (In Persian)
Kleemann, J., Struve, B., & Spyra, M. (2023). Conflicts in urban peripheries in Europe. Land Use Policy, 1(133):106849. 10.1016/j.landusepol.2023.106849.
Kreitner, R., & Kinicki, A. (2009). Organizational Behavior 9Edition. New York: Paul Ducham.
Mashhad Municipality Planning Group. (2018). Regional Section of the Medium-Term Plan of Mashhad Municipality, Samen Region. Mashhad: Samen Region Municipality Publications of Mashhad. (In Persian)
Meyer, Frederick. (2019). Narrative and collective action (Why do political and social appeals need stories?), Translated by Elham Shushtarizadeh. Tehran: Aparat Publications. (In Persian)
Mohammadi Tabaee, M., Malek Afzali, A., Boochani, M. (2023). An analysis of the conflicts between power and interest structures in the planning process of redevelopment of coffee lands (a case study of redevelopment of garages in the neighborhood behind the garages of Zahedan city). Economics and Urban Planning. 4(1), 146-157. 10.22034/UEP.2023.385230.1328. (In Persian)
Motaghi, T., Rafiian, M., Saremi, H. (2021). A theoretical model of contemporaryization based on conflict management in historical urban contexts (Ray city). Naqsh-e Jahan.11(2), 120-136.https://dorl.net/dor/20.1001.1.2322 4991.1400.11.2.7.2. (In Persian)
Nae, M., Dumitrache, L., Suditu, B., & Matei, E. (2019). Housing activism initiatives and land-use conflicts: Pathways for participatory planning and urban sustainable development in Bucharest city, Romania. Sustainability, 11(22), 6211. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11226211.
Nischal, S. (2014). Application of Thomas Kilmann Conflict Resolution Mechanism for Conflict Management in HR of Manufacturing Sector. IISUniv.J.Com.Mgt. Vol.3(1), 62-70.
Rahim, M. (1983). A measure of styles of handling interpersonal conflict. Management, Vol. 26, No. 2, 368-376.
Rahim, M. (2001). Managing conflict in organizations. United States of America: Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc.
Robbins, S. P., & Judge, T. A. (2016). Organizational Behavior 17th edition. United States: Pearson Education.
Robbins, Stephen. (2007). Organizational Behavior (Concepts, Theories, Applications), Translated by Ali Parsaian, Mohammad Arabi. Tehran: Cultural Research Office Publications. (In Persian)
Saeednia, A. (2019). Urban Land Use (Green Book 1400 No. 2). Tehran: Urban and Rural Planning Studies Center Publications. (In Persian)
The Getty Conservation Institute. (2009). Urban Environment Conservation Challenges and Priorities for Action. Meeting Report. Los Angeles.
Vahedi Yeganeh, F., Meshkini, A. and Mohammadi, A. (2022). Analysis of the role of development-stimulating projects in realizing regeneration policies (Case study: Central area of Sanandaj city), Journal of Economics and Planning Urban, 3(3), 196-211 10.22034/UEP.2022.356966.1273. (In Persian)
Vice President for Research of the University of Tehran. (2019). A detailed plan of the context surrounding the holy shrine of Imam Reza (AS), Volume of Urban Planning Studies. Tehran: University of Tehran. (In Persian)
Wang, N., & Wu, G. (2020). A Systematic Approach to Effective Conflict Management for Program. SAGE Open, Original Research, 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244019899055.
Yazdan Niaz, A., Behzadfar, M., and Daneshpour, Abdolhadi (2022). Spatial analysis of social-spatial alternatives in inefficient urban fabrics, case study: Qaytariyeh neighborhood, Tehran, Journal of Economics and Urban Planning, 4(1), 158-179. 10.22034/UEP.2023.386146.1331. (In Persian)
Zhanga, Y., Lia, A., & Fung, T. (2012). Using GIS and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis for Conflict Resolution in Land Use Planning. Procedia Environmental Sciences,13, 2264 – 2273. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proenv.2012.01.215.